On November 5, a judge of the U.S. Federal Claims Court ruled that the SpaceX manned lunar lander contract awarded by NASA to Elon Musk earlier this year was reasonable and legal, Thus ending the legal war that lasted for months < p > it is reported that NASA's cooperation with SpaceX on the development of the lunar module has been temporarily suspended, but will be restarted next Monday < p > Bezos said in his tweet, "this is not the decision we want, but we respect the court's ruling and wish NASA and SpaceX every success in executing the contract." this may imply that his company will not appeal further < p > < / P > < p > Elon Musk, CEO of SpaceX, also commented on the ruling on twitter. Musk responded to the information about the ruling with the poster in the 1995 film judge Dredd, saying: "you have been sentenced." < / P > < p > the previous blue origin litigation document said that SpaceX ignored security issues. After the ruling, the company said it was actively cooperating with NASA on a number of projects < p > a spokesman for blue origin said: "our lawsuit highlights the human landing system Important safety issues still to be solved in the procurement process. A fair procurement process, including redundant systems and sound policies to promote competition, is required to return astronauts to the moon safely through NASA's public-private partnership model. Blue origin is still committed to helping the Artemis Project succeed. "< / P > < p > NASA said, Blue origin will have more opportunities to cooperate with NASA. A spokesman for the agency said: "in addition to this contract, NASA will continue to cooperate with many companies to strengthen competition and make full preparations for astronauts landing on the moon." NASA will build a lunar base under the framework of Artemis program, and all companies will have opportunities for cooperation. " < / P > < p > < / P > < p > NASA awarded SpaceX the only contract for the agency's HLS project through competitive bidding in April this year. The contract is worth $2.9 billion. SpaceX will use its starship to send astronauts to the lunar surface for NASA's upcoming Artemis mission < p > SpaceX competed with blue origin and U.S. defense contractor dynetics for two contracts expected to be signed. Later, NASA awarded only one contract because Congress allocated less money for the project than expected < p > Blue origin soon protested to the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO), but the latter rejected the company's complaint in late July, leading to Bezos's space company to upgrade its legal action. Blue origin said that the focus of the company's lawsuit was to prove that NASA wrongly awarded the contract to SpaceX and "ignored key flight safety requirements" in the process < p > the ruling of Richard Hertling, a judge of the United States Federal Claims Court, refutes the claim of blue origin. The court's opinion is currently sealed because the case contains proprietary information of the two companies, but hutlin ordered the lawyers of the two sides to meet on November 18 to negotiate what they want to modify < p > NASA's cooperation with SpaceX on the HLS contract was suspended during the litigation, but it is planned to resume next Monday < p > judge hutlin's ruling is another blow to the ambition of blue origin. After resigning as CEO of Amazon, Bezos was more involved in the affairs of blue origin. Although the company has successfully conducted two suborbital manned flights so far, it has always been affected by soaring employee turnover, frequent safety problems and allegations of "toxic work culture" by former employees < p > however, blue origin is always striving to realize the company vision set by Bezos, that is, "millions of people live and work in space to benefit the earth", especially "transfer the industries that put pressure on the earth to space". Last month, blue origin announced the establishment of a private space station in cooperation with a number of companies, with the goal of deploying it in orbit around 2030 < p > NASA may also award contracts to blue origin and dynetics in the future, depending on the funds received by the agency in the future. Jim bridenstine, former NASA director, testified before the Senate Commerce, science and Transportation Committee that he believed that NASA should have at least two lunar lander suppliers. The draft NASA budget released by the Senate Appropriations Committee in October also instructed NASA to choose a second supplier. (Xiaoxiao, Chenchen) < / P > < p >