Share the QR code < / P > < p > with wechat scanning code to friends and circles of friends < / P > < p > Author: Peng Ningling < / P > < p > recently, the issue of "law students in Beijing and Shanghai suing apple for not sending chargers" has aroused heated discussion. Since Apple canceled the charger and headset of iPhone 12 series products, more and more mobile phone businesses have begun to follow this practice in recent years < p > some people support the prosecution of law students, while others believe that it is purely a matter of heat and meaningless. Has the practice of mobile phone manufacturers infringed on the rights and interests of consumers < p > data figure: Apple CEO Tim Cook preached at the new product launch < p > increase profits in the name of environmental protection According to media reports, because Apple's new products no longer give power adapters, students from Beijing University of chemical technology and Donghua University teamed up to take apple to court in May this year, requesting apple to deliver mobile phone chargers, bear liability for breach of contract, pay liquidated damages of 100 yuan and bear litigation costs < p > the case was heard in the first instance in September this year. In the court, both the plaintiff and the defendant conducted a cross examination of evidence. At present, the case is still in the stage of supplementary evidence and written materials < p > "the first feeling is, well done!" an iPhone 12 user told chinanews.com that he felt very unreasonable when he heard that buying a mobile phone did not have a charger. "When I buy a mobile phone, I have to spend hundreds more to buy a charging head!" < / P > < p > it can also be seen from the comments of netizens that many people have deep resentment about buying a mobile phone without a charger < p > in fact, this is not the first time Apple has been sued for charger < p > in 2020, apple cancelled the power adapter and headset attached to iPhone 12 series products on the grounds of "environmental protection" and "everyone has ready-made accessories". In January 2021, "apple did not send the charger to court" and rushed to the overheating search < p > from enterprise check microblog < p > according to the official microblog of Enterprise Investigation on January 27, Mr. Yang, a consumer in Xi'an, raised a substantive challenge to apple and took apple to court on the fact that the new mobile phone accessories did not include a charger < p > Mr. Yang made several major appeals: ordered the defendant (Apple) to replace the usb-c to lightning connection cable with the usb-a to lightning connection cable free of charge; The defendant Apple was ordered by law to provide a charging adapter matching the usb-a lightning connection cable < p > however, the following is not seen in this case. Qicha microblog mentioned that qicha app showed that the court session date was January 26, but apple did not appear in court in time and did not respond < p > since then, many domestic mobile phone manufacturers have begun to follow this practice < p > a mobile phone brand < p > chinanews.com inquired at the official flagship stores of several well-known mobile phone brands. The customer service of a brand store said that in the store, the "official standard" version of mobile phone has no charger and data cable, "package 1" has charger and data cable, and the price of "official standard" is 200 yuan lower than that of "package 1" < p > the customer service of another brand replied: "in response to environmental protection, charger and data cable will not be provided". You can choose package purchase. The package provided shows that the price is the same whether there is a charger or not < p > "Apple's behavior is just to increase corporate profits by reducing consumers' necessary accessories in the name of environmental protection." in this lawsuit, a law student from Beijing University of chemical technology mentioned that Apple promoted MagSafe wireless charger under the sales interface of iPhone 12. Wireless charging is the charging method with the lowest conversion efficiency. Apple vigorously promotes wireless charging, which puts the practical value of wireless charging before the value of environmental protection; Instead of the power adapter, it puts the practical value of the charger behind the environmental protection value < p > according to previous media reports, Apple's new smartphone iPhone 13 may soon face punishment in Brazil because it does not come with a free charging plug < p > it is reported that in March this year, Brazil fined Apple $1.9 million for similar problems, and apple lost a related civil lawsuit in Brazil. In the view of Brazilian consumer protection agencies, the practice of Apple phones without chargers is equivalent to a disguised price increase < p > useless show < p > lawyer: This is also safeguarding the rights of other apple consumers < / P > < p > after the news came out, many netizens expressed support for safeguarding the rights, and some netizens questioned: is there really no way to take them? "Buying a mobile phone without a charger is the same as buying instant noodles without seasoning. I haven't heard of buying seasoning." < / P > < p > some people also think that since there is an explanation in advance not to send a charger, why not buy so many brands? I think this behavior is only eye-catching < p > on the legal issues in this incident, Lawyer Zhang Xinnian of Beijing Zhongwen law firm said in an interview with chinanews.com that in fact, it is well known that without a charger, the mobile phone will not work normally, and the charger should be standard for mobile phones; Legally, the mobile phone can be regarded as the main object in the sales contract, and the charger is an accessory, and apple mobile phone can only be equipped with apple charger < p > "therefore, even if Apple told consumers not to provide chargers in the standard terms, it is suspected of violating their contractual obligations." < / P > < p > Zhang Xinnian said that previously, all businesses, including apple, have distributed chargers when consumers buy mobile phones, which has formed a market trading practice and Apple should abide by < p > for the statement of "eye popping", lawyers believe that when consumers think their legitimate rights and interests have been infringed, they have the right to seek judicial relief and bring a lawsuit to the court according to law, and the students' rights protection should be affirmed < p > "this lawsuit has public welfare value, and students are actually defending the rights of other apple consumers." Zhang Xinnian said that once the lawsuit is won, Apple should solve the same problems faced by other consumers < p > related reading: < / P > < p > rush to hot search! Five female college students teamed up to sue apple! Because there is no charger < / P > < p > daily economic news < / P > < p > < / P > < p > every time edited by he Xiaotao Yi Qijiang gaiyuanyuan < / P > < p > on October 26, the topic of "French students suing apple" rushed to a hot search and attracted attention < p > according to the Shanghai rule of law newspaper, Fang classmate, a law student at Beijing University of chemical technology, bought iPhone 12 & nbsp; Pro Max mobile phone, after finding that the mobile phone is not equipped with corresponding charging equipment, chooses to safeguard its rights and interests by legal means. "According to the habit of transferring the subordinate with the main thing and social transactions, the purchase of mobile phones should be equipped with chargers." < / P > < p > five female students from Beijing University of chemical technology and Donghua University teamed up to take apple to court. In May 2021, Fang and his little sister ?
2023-03-22 10:04:46